| First aired:|
May 15, 2006
Ted makes a final attempt to win Robin's heart. Marshall and Lily's relationship is in jeopardy.
Ted, having given up his previous date with his supposedly perfect match, has decided to pursue Robin yet again. Barney (acting on behalf of the Universe) slaps Ted, telling him it's a bad idea. Ted tells them that he will try only one more time, and if it does not work out, he will accept that it is not meant to be. He then surprises her in her apartment with candy, flowers, and a group of musicians with blue instruments (in reference to the Blue French horn he stole for her on their first date).
Robin, while surprised, cannot give Ted a definite answer, especially after he learned that Robin's company camping trip is back on and Sandy Rivers is trying to date her now that he is moving on to CNN. Ted finally accuses Robin of ignoring her true feelings and urges her to "touch the ground", but it fails to win her over. Ted walks out frustrated, but breaks his promise by trying to get Robin again by doing a rain dance. After he convinces a girl Barney hooked up with twice to help him (as she has a Ph.D in Native American studies), Ted tries to do a rain dance, which ultimately proves successful, and he then goes over to Robin's. Ted yells up to her from the street, telling her to come down (alluding to his previous demands for her to "touch the ground"), and the two finally become a couple.
While Ted is finally finding success, Marshall is encountering the opposite. After having learned about Lily's acceptance into an art fellowship in San Francisco, he begins to worry that their relationship is in danger. Marshall and Lily argue almost non-stop as to what will happen and Lily reveals that, despite having promised herself she would not go, she actually wants to, even though the wedding is only weeks away. Due to the length of their arguments, Marshall and Lily have developed a "pause function", allowing them to temporarily drop the argument to do something else. As the argument reaches a head, Lily tries to pause the argument but Marshall refuses, which leads to the two having sex.
As Ted heads back in a cab from Robin's apartment, Future Ted tells his kids that although New York looked the same, in one night everything had changed. Ted's high spirits quickly dampen when he finds Marshall sitting on the steps of the apartment complex in the rain, with Lily having gone to San Francisco and called off the engagement. Ted comforts him, knowing that Marshall has lost the only girl he had ever loved.
- Ted mentions stealing the Blue French Horn for Robin in the Pilot when he comes up with his plan to hire a string quartet with blue instruments.
- Sandy mentions reading the newspaper to his viewers each morning, a segment of Metro News 1 previously referenced in Mary the Paralegal.
- Lily feels the consequences of her interview from Milk when Marshall hears the message about it on the answering machine.
- The LAMA (Local Area Media Award) that Robin won in Mary the Paralegal can be seen in Robin's apartment to the right of the blue French horn.
Future References (Contains Spoilers)
- Lily and Marshall eventually get back together in Swarley.
- In Slap Bet, Robin mentions Derek being the last person she dated before Ted, and he indeed was before she and Ted get together here.
- Marshall calls dibs when Lily mentions there being one more pudding snack pack in the fridge. His love of pudding snack packs is seen again in Monday Night Football
- Penelope says that she and Barney had sex twice in his car. However, in Arrivederci, Fiero, he says he never learnt how to drive and demonstrates a fear of driving. This means he once had a car without knowing how to drive it.
- While it's possible Barney was using a car that wasn't his to seduce women, it seems unlikely as he would have had to use the same car twice to have sex with Penelope. Nevertheless, they could have had sex twice in the car on the same occasion.
- In Shelter Island, Robin mentions Ted trying to make it rain (Ted argues that he did in fact make it rain).
- Barney informs Ted that waiting naked in a girl's apartment wearing whipped cream underwear usually does not work, but begins telling about a time when it did work before Lily slaps him. The gang learn about a similar technique for seducing women, waiting completely naked, in The Naked Man.
- This may also be an allusion to Zip, Zip, Zip, where Barney starts undressing in Robin's apartment and she turns him down.
- Sandy returns as Robin's boss at World Wide News in Bad News.
- In Bass Player Wanted, Lily and Marshall "pause" their fight over Marshall's New York judgeship. They "unpause" the fight in Unpause, and Marshall reveals that, after seven years, he still hasn't forgiven Lily for leaving him and going to San Francisco.
|Lily:||Look, I know this sucks. It's just something I'm going through. I'm not asking you to understand it. I'm not asking you to be happy about it. I'm just asking you to support it.|
|Marshall:||Look, I want to, Lily, okay? I really do. But I just can't.|
|Marshall:||Because you're scaring the hell out of me. That's why not. What if you decide to go be a painter, and then you realize I don't fit into your life anymore, and three months becomes forever? Can you promise me that that's not gonna happen?|
|Barney:||Ted! You're forcing me to be the voice of reason, and it's not a good look for me!|
|Sandy Rivers:||Bummer. I was hoping to finally have sex with you this weekend, Scherbatsky.|
|Robin:||Well, I'd give you the "I don't date coworkers" speech again, but God, you must have that sumbitch memorized by now.|
|Ted:||Screw that. This ain't over.|
|Marshall:||Ted, you sat here in this very booth and you said-|
|Ted:||I don't care what I said. This is gonna happen. She can't say it's not meant to be. It is meant to be, and you know why? 'Cause I mean it to be.|
|Ted:||Robin I've sort of said this already. I mean I've half said it. I've tried to say it, and I've said it badly. So this is me, just saying it. With strings. I'm crazy about you. I think we should be together. What do you say? What do you say?|
|Robin:||Yes... No... I don't know...|
|Ted:||Those are the three options.|
|Barney:||Robin again? Ted, the universe clearly does not want you and Robin to be together. Don't piss off the universe. The universe will slap you.|
|Ted:||But don't you think the universe has more important things to worry about than my dating life?|
|Marshall:||Unless your dating life is the glue holding the entire universe together... Whoa. Chills. Anybody else get chills?|
|Ted:||Look, I realize we've been down this road before, but the fact is, whatever I do, it all keeps coming back to Robin, so... I gotta do this.
(Barney slaps him)
|Ted:||Ow! What the hell?|
|Barney:||That wasn't me. That was the universe.|
|Barney:||Ted, waiting naked in a girl's bed wearing whipped cream undies does not work... usually. The setting - Martha's Vineyard, 1999. The characters: Yours truly and a raven-haired au pair by the name-|
|Lily:||(Slaps him. He stares aghast) Universe.|
|Future Ted:||Let's pause. See, Marshall and Lily had a rule that at any point during a fight they could pause and take a break. Their fights often lasted for days.|
|Lily:||No, there's no crying in pause-land. Pause-land is a happy place full of popcorn shrimp mountains and buttersauce rivers!|
|Barney:||These are your awesome years, you're wasting them on this girl. This isn't going to work.|
|Ted:||I know it.|
|Barney:||Well then why are you doing this?|
|Ted:||Because I love her! I love her! I told her the first night we met and here we are eight months later and nothing's changed. So I know this isn't going to work. (Looks towards the sky) But it has to work! You hear me universe?! This is Ted Mosby talking! Give me some rain! Come On! Come On! Come On! (It starts raining)|
|Barney:||Oh, come on!|
Notes and Trivia
Goofs and Errors
- When Robin is talking to Ted through her window her hair is not completely wet. However when she pulls her head in her hair is completely wet.
- When Ted asks Robin "What do you say?", the screen fades to black, and fades back in with him asking the same question. The string quartet are at a different point in their music (Air on the G String) the second time he is shown asking the question.
Allusions and Outside References
- Robin says she planned to come home and watch Jeopardy!.
- Ted's successful plan to make it rain and the gigantic storm that resulted in his rain dance is a reference to the legend of Charles Hatfield who was a pioneer in rainmaking known for creating a formula that caused a flood in San Diego in 1916.
- Marshall and Lily eat at Red Lobster, where he cries, and Lily says, "There's no crying in pause land ..." (an obvious reference to Tom Hanks' character, Jimmy Dugan, in A League of Their Own: "There's no crying in baseball ...")
- Ted jokes to Penelope that he is going to get brain surgery from a guy who's seen some episodes of ER.
- The five main cast members (Radnor, Hannigan, Harris, Segal, Smulders) provided audio commentary for the episode. The commentary track is available on the season 1 DVD.
- Amy Acker, who played Penelope, previously worked with Alyson Hannigan once on the TV series Angel, with Hannigan portraying Willow Rosenberg and Acker portraying Fred Burkle.
- Alexis Denisof, who plays the recurring character Sandy Rivers, is Alyson Hannigan's husband. He also co-stared with Amy Acker on the TV series Angel as well as the 2012 film version of Much Ado About Nothing.
- Neil Patrick Harris cried at the end of the episode after he watched it for the first time.
- Josh Radnor said that he and Jason Segel were freezing in that episode as the water was so cold. He even said that when looking up at Robin the cold water was stinging his eyes.
- Amy Acker - Penelope
- Suzanne Ford - Vet
- Alexis Denisof - Sandy Rivers
- Robert Michael Morris - Lou
- Mark Gagliardi - Quartet Leader
- The St. Petersburg Comic Review gave this episode 8.5 out of 10 stars. "What a cliffhanger! They expect us to wait four months to see where this goes?"
|Milk||Come On |
|Where Were We?|